emergency loan
Shaliah Ruth

How to Avoid Taking a Second Emergency Loan to Cover the First

A second emergency loan usually doesn’t happen because you “need more money.” It happens because the first repayment lands before essentials, your account runs dry, and the fastest option looks like another loan. The way out is simple: stabilise cashflow, change the first repayment plan early, and use targeted help for the bill that triggered the shortfall.

If You’re About to Apply for Another Loan, Pause and Do This First

Before you apply, assume one thing: if you’re short now, adding another repayment will probably make next week tighter, not easier. Your goal is to stop the spiral, not to keep it moving.

A 2 Minute Self Check: Are You Short, or Are You Unstable?

Work out the gap in dollars for this pay cycle

Use the next 7 to 14 days only.

Income you expect to receive this pay cycle, minus essentials you must pay this pay cycle, minus the first loan repayment due, equals the gap.

If the number is positive, you’re short-term stressed but potentially stable. If it’s negative, you’re unstable. A second loan won’t fix that because it adds another repayment on top of a gap that already exists.

If the gap is negative, another loan doesn’t solve it

A second loan can feel like relief because it delays pain. But it usually converts one problem into two repayments, two fees, and less control over your bank account.

The Real Reason People Re-Borrow

Repayments hit before essentials

Many emergency loans are structured so repayments come out on payday or shortly after. If that withdrawal leaves you without enough for rent, food, transport, or utilities, the next “solution” becomes another loan.

Tight schedules and fees make the shortfall worse

When repayment schedules are tight, missing one payment can trigger fees and extra contact. That pressure pushes people into fast decisions.

Stress decisions and fast approval pressure

When you’re stressed, speed feels like safety. That’s exactly when the wrong product feels right.

The No-Second-Loan Plan (Next 24 Hours)

  1. Contact the lender and ask for hardship or a payment plan. Tell them what changed, what you can pay, and how long you need. Don’t wait for a missed payment.
  2. Make the next repayment safe. If a direct debit will wipe out essentials, move the repayment to an arrangement you can control. The goal is to keep life stable while you fix the loan.
  3. Set a temporary amount you can repeat. A smaller payment that you can make every pay cycle beats an optimistic promise you’ll break in 7 days.

What to Ask For So You Don’t Need Another Loan

Keep it practical. Ask for one short-term change that gives breathing room, such as reduced repayments for a set period, a brief pause followed by a step up plan, fee relief linked to hardship, or a term extension that spreads arrears across the remaining term. If the lender offers an option that still leaves you short for essentials, it’s not a solution.

Better Options Than a Second Emergency Loan (By Situation)

Use the option that matches what caused the emergency. This is how you avoid turning a one-off bill into an ongoing debt cycle.

What triggered the shortfall Best next move Who to contact What you’ll need
Utility bill, phone, internet Ask for a payment plan or hardship support Your retailer or provider Your next pay date and an affordable amount
Medical, dental, essential appliances, car repair Check if you’re eligible for a no interest option before borrowing again A NILS provider (often through community organisations) A quote for the item or service
Income drop or hours cut Ask the lender for hardship and reset repayments around your new income Your lender’s hardship team Proof of reduced income and a basic budget
Rent stress or moving costs Talk to a financial counsellor before borrowing again National Debt Helpline Rent amount, income, and a list of debts
The first loan repayment is the problem Negotiate a plan before the next debit hits Lender hardship team A realistic repayment proposal

If You’ve Already Taken the Second Loan

Don’t waste time trying to “juggle” both repayments. Treat it as a cashflow problem and fix it at the source.

Start by stopping new applications for a short period so you can see your real position. Then contact both lenders and request hardship or payment plan help that fits your actual budget. If you can’t get a workable plan quickly, get free help from a financial counsellor so you don’t end up trapped in constant top ups.

Red Flags That Signal You’re Being Pulled Into Repeat Borrowing

Scripts and Templates

30 second phone script

“Hi, I’m calling about my loan repayment due on [date]. My income has changed because [reason]. I can’t meet the current repayment without missing essentials. I’m asking for hardship help or a payment plan. I can pay $[amount] each [week/fortnight] for the next [timeframe], then review. What information do you need from me, and when will I get a decision?”

Short email template

Subject: Hardship request and repayment plan

“My loan reference is [number]. My income has changed due to [reason], and I can’t meet the next repayment on [date] without hardship. I’m requesting a temporary repayment change. I can pay $[amount] each [week/fortnight] for [timeframe], then review. Please confirm what documents you need and the decision timeframe in writing.”

One page budget snapshot

Keep it simple: income per pay cycle, essentials per pay cycle, existing debt repayments per pay cycle, and what is left. If what is left is negative, your plan needs a repayment reduction or pause, not a new loan.

When to Escalate to AFCA

If the lender refuses to help, stalls, or only offers an option you can’t afford, ask for internal dispute resolution in writing. If you still can’t reach a workable outcome, escalate to AFCA. If you feel overwhelmed or the numbers don’t add up, call the National Debt Helpline early and get a financial counsellor on your side.

FAQs

Is taking a second emergency loan ever a good idea?

It’s usually a warning sign, not a solution. If you need a second loan to cover the first, your budget doesn’t support the repayments. The better move is to change the repayment plan on the first loan and stabilise essentials.

What should I say to my lender if I can’t meet the next repayment?

Tell them the cause of the shortfall, what you can pay, and how long you need. Ask for hardship help or a payment plan and ask for the response in writing.

Can I change repayments if my income dropped suddenly?

Often, yes. If you have a reasonable cause and you can show what you can afford, lenders can consider reduced repayments, short pauses, or step up plans. The key is asking early and giving enough information.

What are safer alternatives to a payday loan in Australia?

Start with payment plans and hardship support for the bill that triggered the emergency. If you’re eligible, a no interest loan can help for essential goods and services. A financial counsellor can also help you negotiate and avoid repeat borrowing.

When should I get a financial counsellor involved or escalate to AFCA?

Get support early if you’re already considering a second loan, if repayments would leave you short for essentials, or if the lender isn’t offering a workable plan. Escalate to AFCA if you can’t reach a fair, affordable outcome through the lender.

Sources